The Accidental Prime Minister: The Making and Unmaking of Manmohan Singh is a memoir by Indian policy analyst Sanjaya Baru, who was Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's media advisor from May to August Published by Penguin India, the book alleges that Singh was not entirely in. The Accidental Prime Minister book. Read reviews from the world's largest community for readers. In Sanjaya Baru left a successful career as chi. For the American reader, The Accidental Prime Minister is an education in This is the political environment Baru artfully describes in his book.
|Language:||English, Spanish, Japanese|
|Genre:||Politics & Laws|
|Distribution:||Free* [*Registration needed]|
maroc-evasion.info - download The Accidental Prime Minister: The Making and Unmaking of Manmohan Singh book online at best prices in India on maroc-evasion.info Read The. The Prime Minister s Office called the book a work of fiction. The Accidental Prime Minister and millions of other books are available for site Kindle. It is a measure of how committed The Accidental Prime Minister is to gritty authenticity that Sanjaya Baru, on whose book the film is based.
There are a couple of scenes where Dr Singh is shown to be struggling to speak in Parliament amid chaos. But the camera remains fixed on the Treasury benches and no protest by the Opposition benches -- then largely occupied by the Bharatiya Janata Party -- is shown. So, it is all about how Dr Singh was attacked by the media and left to fend for himself by his party and no word of what the BJP leaders used to say about Dr Singh back then.
At many places, Baru's character, played by Akshaye Khanna, passes opinions -- not necessarily part of the book -- which tend to suit the popular political narrative against the Gandhis. The movie also contains a dramatic representation of Rahul Gandhi's infamous interview with Arnab Goswami, with Goswami's character having an expression of disgust that the anchor didn't actually have.
If one is able to find these subtle ways in which the movie takes on the Gandhis, one may find it to be a well-made movie. It nicely brings out Baru's affection for Dr Singh, successfully capturing the incidents narrated in the book where Baru projected a strong image of the PM and where he tried to convince him to take credit for his work, not let it go to Rahul or Sonia. In terms of acting, Anupam Kher has tried his best to portray Dr Singh.
Granted, it was hard for him to make his voice so feeble and still sound natural, but there are no excuses for his overdramatic walk. Notwithstanding the book describing Patel as being 'polite and deferential' towards the PM, the movie shows him always passing snide remarks. But undoubtedly the most dramatised character is that of Baru, played by Khanna -- a flamboyant man with a diverse wardrobe having immense charm and wit. This presentation has given Khanna a chance to show his superior acting skills, making his character most influential, certainly according to the script's demand.
It can be said that the movie would have been judged better by both sides of the political aisle had it appeared while the UPA was in power. It could have conveyed why India's Grand Old Party should not have been hijacked by one family. Or why a person like Dr Singh must be taken seriously. But in 'New India', a list of leaders has been made who were denied their due by 'the family' and it contains everyone from Sardar Patel to Narasimha Rao, the latest addition being Sitaram Kesri.
The movie tries to put Dr Singh also on that list. However, it is uncertain if the makers of this list are ready to include him as yet. After all, he's still very much a part of the Congress and keeps criticising the government over all major issues. Lastly, one may say the movie will attract two sets of viewers -- those who follow politics and know what has happened in the country in the past two decades and those who woke up to Indian politics only during the Lok Sabha election.
For the latter, the movie will certainly strengthen their dislike for the Gandhi family while some may also feel for Dr Singh. Did Manmohan fight with Sonia? Five years later, a movie based on the book also fails to do the same.
Are you a Movie buff? The books reads well. It should. The author is a senior journalist.
Thi Who can afford to not read the biggest publishing phenomenon in India in the last decade? This is not a biography and not a authoritative examination of the Prime Ministerial career of Dr.
Manmohan Singh. It is an account of what a prime minister's press secretary saw. On principle, that is limiting and therefore unsatisfactory.
The author did not serve the Prime Minister throughout his term. He wasn't there when Dr Manmohan Singh started to seriously decline and fall. Given the limitation the author has imposed on himself, he is unable to tell us exactly how this happened though why finds a brief comment. All in all, I am delighted the genre has made a beginning but disappointed at how modest it has turned out to be.
So when we get down to discussing why this extraordinary man declined and fell, the reasons are still taken from the newspapers and not this book. Jan 05, Hajarath Prasad Abburu rated it really liked it. A very good and mostly accurate memoir of a journalist turned media advisor to the only Congress Prime Minister to serve two full terms hailing from a Non Nehru-Gandhi family.
It's a very tricky book to write considering how it isn't a swansong or even a work of hatred. The author was mostly balanced and tried to remain objective in judging the Prime Minister and others. Good read for people who would like to read about the inner workings of South Block and who want to know more about the behind A very good and mostly accurate memoir of a journalist turned media advisor to the only Congress Prime Minister to serve two full terms hailing from a Non Nehru-Gandhi family.
Good read for people who would like to read about the inner workings of South Block and who want to know more about the behind the scenes of Nuke deal. Apr 16, Sujash Baid rated it it was amazing. A helpless Bheeshma of our times! This book is the first of a kind which provides an insiders account to how things unfolded during the first tenure of the UPA government. Manmohan Singh and how he managed to run the coalition.
This book is an account of how a good, wise and a learned man was put on the wrong side defending a disreputable lot. Manmohan Singh is the case of a person who has been stabbed time and again by his colleagues, by the fellow A helpless Bheeshma of our times! Manmohan Singh is the case of a person who has been stabbed time and again by his colleagues, by the fellow politicians of his party.
This book to some extent has tried to capture the reasons behind the policy paralysis. Apr 17, Deepak Rao rated it liked it. After reading the book I can only say that media reports have been very selective while reporting about this book.
Definitely, an undue emphasis has been given to the latter part of the book's title while deciding on the theme of these reports. My respect for Dr. Singh has only increased after reading the book. Every great man has certain failings which are often retrospectively attributed to him while criticising his work and life. But the eclipse of Sun shouldn't make us conclude that it never sh After reading the book I can only say that media reports have been very selective while reporting about this book.
But the eclipse of Sun shouldn't make us conclude that it never shone brightly. I agree with him when Dr. Singh says that history will be kinder to him and he will get due credit for what he has done for India. May 04, Amit Tyagi rated it really liked it. Sanjaya Baru needs to be praised for taking the bold some may say, controversial step of deciding to write this book. Our politicians and bureaucrats prefer to take the refuge of sensitive matters and official secrets in order to justify their decision of not coming out with their memoirs.
But, this is precisely the kind of transparency that we need, of a view inside the corridors of power, who lobbies for whom, what motivates the various characters and so on.
Coming to the book, Sanjaya Baru de Sanjaya Baru needs to be praised for taking the bold some may say, controversial step of deciding to write this book. Coming to the book, Sanjaya Baru deserves credit for the structure that he has given to the book. I guess, having been an editor for most of his professional career definitely helped. Also, despite claims in mainstream media to the contrary, the book is as pro-Mammohan Singh as it can get while retaining objectivity.
Infact the book is very critical of the Congressis who nursed ambitions for the PM post and also Sonia Gandhi to an extent.
What was more interesting for me, is how much of our foreign policy is influenced by the communal considerations of the so called secularists. Apr 23, Santhosh Guru rated it it was ok. A little laborious read, if you are following-up the politics of India for the last decade. It is laborious not because of the style of writing but the content. The entire book tries to say that Manmohan Singh is an honest, gentleman politician and an able economist, became a prime minister but could not wield his power because omnipotent Sonia controlling him and the government.
Manmohan Singh's vision on external affairs and relationship with Pakistan is really a key take away for me from this A little laborious read, if you are following-up the politics of India for the last decade.
Manmohan Singh's vision on external affairs and relationship with Pakistan is really a key take away for me from this book. His vision that the borders cannot be changed and it can be made irrelevant is really an impressive thought and its a pity that he could put it in action because of various political reasons in India as well as Pakistan. But apart from the above, all other things discussed in the book is nothing phenomenal. We knew that he was crippled by the coalition politics and his puppeteer was Sonia.
This books goes in elaborate ways to corroborate this. Jan 29, S. Ach rated it liked it Shelves: Loads and loads of information, and many times, about unimportant events. Tons of name droppings and glorification of one's own contributions. Poor story-telling to hold the attention of the reader. Deliberate shunning of controversial subjects. Jul 09, Anashuya Kakati rated it really liked it. The book gives a clear idea about how complex it is to run a government.
There are so many participants, all precariously strung together, and contrary to public opinion 'the first among the equal' is not, in fact, the most powerful. Though Dr. Singh was more submissive than an usual PM, but I feel even a PM with a majority would have as many factions in his own party to keep happy.
For the common man, who demands changes in days, this book is a MUST. Running a government is a mammoth task an The book gives a clear idea about how complex it is to run a government. Running a government is a mammoth task and we are too eager to rush to judgements. We love to portray our leaders in black or white, but in reality to run a successful government '50 shades of grey' are needed.
The intricate details that go into policy making is well enunciated by the author. The nuclear bill and Dr. Singh's struggle starting with the Americans to his own party members is an eye opener. The irony of a democracy is well spelt out by Dr.
Baru about how the biggest blows a PM gets are from his own rather than from the opposition. When I read this book the only image I could think of is that of Dr. Singh as the Greek hero Sisyphus rolling the big boulder up the hill only to watch it roll back down. The only thing I wonder is what made an erudite scholar like him roll the boulder for two terms? Was it ambition, or loyalty or just mere acceptance of fate? The book is a love letter.
Platonic might I add, but a love letter nevertheless written by a student for his much beloved 'Guru'. Baru tries very hard to be critical but the chapter 'Manmohan's Camelot' is written in earnest admiration and is not mere flattery. Lastly, I wish Dr.
Singh would also put pen to paper and leave his legacy behind. He said that 'Public office offers the opportunity to be educated at public expense'. Well Dr. Singh, public office also demands the education of the Public. Apr 20, Sudheendra Chaitanya rated it really liked it. To those of us who have no inkling of what happens in the top corridors of government, how power is viewed from within, how decisions are taken, how human ambition meets the most important issues that face the country, this book is quite a revelation.
It appears matter-of-fact. That top decisions are never about morality or rightness, but they are the output of a few humans jostling for power and limelight, is another thing worth seeing.
We need to see To those of us who have no inkling of what happens in the top corridors of government, how power is viewed from within, how decisions are taken, how human ambition meets the most important issues that face the country, this book is quite a revelation.
We need to see more such books about the Indian political scene, some sort of a factual insider view. Jan 18, shashank sourabh rated it really liked it. Dr Singh,despite being the most 'qualified' politician in the world,struggled with the public perception of being a weak Prime Minister throughout his two terms. The book tells us why the perception was wrong and right. A must read for anyone interested in Indian politics. May 14, Hrishikesh rated it liked it. An insider's story into what transpired during UPA It is no secret that Dr.
Manmohan Singh was the accidental Prime Minister. Sanjay Baru was not just his media advisor, he was also a trusted confidant. The book presents an hitherto unseen image of Dr.
Personally speaking, it improved my image of Dr. It presents his political acumen - rather the fact that he had any political acumen at all. As Digvijay Singh once said - "I don't know if he's an over-rated economist; but I do know that he is an under-rated politician".
It also shows his thinking and his attempts to run his government.
The reason why the Delhi Durbar is so upset at this book is not because it is critical of Dr. Singh - it is because a it presents Dr. Singh in a better light and b it is critical of Sonia Gandhi and her gang of sycophants. In my opinion the book has historical value, because it will be a strong bulwark against making Dr. Singh the fall-guy for the Congress' decimation in The book presents a simple story - the primary fault lies with Sonia and Rahul Gandhi.
All-in-all, Dr. Singh's role is beyond redemption. He has failed the nation, and there can be no two ways about it. The only silver linings are that a he tried a workable option in a bad fix; no one could have done better and that b if he had resigned, probably a worse person would have taken charge - that is how the Congress functions.
A lot of important lessons to be learnt from this book and a good insight into the Delhi durbars although my favorite does remain Tavleen Singh's narrative.
The perfect description of Dr.
Singh is that provided by Baru himself - that of Bhishma. May 09, Girish Shilamkar rated it really liked it. The book a must read for anyone interested in Indian politics. Sanjay Baru tries to answer the question in the minds of millions of Indians, how Singh who was once hailed as King after nuclear deal with US reduced himself to an object of ridicule.
That is the period when Mr. Baru was PM's media adviser. Dr Singh's contribution of economic liberalisation Mr. Rao played a bigger role h The book a must read for anyone interested in Indian politics. Rao played a bigger role here and signing nuclear deal with US thus ending India's nuclear apartheid, will go down in history as key milestones in development of India.
But the second term has tarnished his legacy for sure. Hence "Gandhi mukt Congress" is better idea than "Congress mukt bharat" as we always need an national an opposition to keep a check on government. In the words of Dr. Manmohan Singh, "I honestly believe that history will be kinder to me than the contemporary media, or for that matter, the Opposition parties in Parliament.. And this cannot be more true. It so happens that the good work done by someone of his calibre is hidden away in the din of noises of useless media chatters and other sycophantic voices.
Singh was and will always remain a charm for his his intellect, his humane persona, his gentle and civil conduct, his political in In the words of Dr.
Singh was and will always remain a charm for his his intellect, his humane persona, his gentle and civil conduct, his political instinct and his deep patriotism. This book outlines well the rough journey he had to undertake in UPA-1 and a bit of his more turbulent journey during UPA It takes through the milestones that Dr. Singh saw during his tenure and the hinderances in the path. Not being chronologically written makes it a bit of a non-reference text, but the inclusion of couplets and quotes in chapters make it interesting.
Looking forward to read more by Sanjaya Baru.
May 20, Aruna Kumar Gadepalli rated it really liked it Shelves: Easy and quick read. The book contains 13 chapters excluding Introduction and Epilogue. In the introduction the author announces various aspects like why he is writing the book what the books deals with and the what are the sources and the maintaining anonymity of the sources in case if anyone asked to do so.
Why I started reading this book.
I Easy and quick read. I was curious why the book got so much attention and why so much is talked about. I did't find any points that are worthy of attention. What it contains already know but in the book authors puts down in print. Interesting narrative. Feb 08, Nikunj rated it really liked it. I have never read such an interesting piece of literature which combines history, current affairs along with psychology.
This book is a must read for any person interested in politics, current affairs of the political landscape of our This is a blow by blow account of the turn of events in PMO during UPA This book is a must read for any person interested in politics, current affairs of the political landscape of our country. Riveting account of happenings in the corridors of high powers, of turf battles, of a fractious opposition, of some double-dealing allies, or a party that failed to put its full support behind a man who accomplished much and could have risen to become one of India's greatest leaders had he been a little firmer in his second term Oct 13, Manas Saloi rated it really liked it.
Nice book on the workings of the PMO. View 2 comments. Feb 03, Abhijeet Aanand rated it really liked it. This one had been on the list since long and much to my expectations, Sanjaya Baru does an excellent job in bringing out the statesman inside Dr. This book has brought in a profound change in my opinion about Dr.
Singh which was initially highly skewed due to his approach in his second term. Most of the hardcore political analysts would hardly find anything substantial in the book but for those who are not acquainted with the scene going inside the corridors, this book would be an This one had been on the list since long and much to my expectations, Sanjaya Baru does an excellent job in bringing out the statesman inside Dr.
Most of the hardcore political analysts would hardly find anything substantial in the book but for those who are not acquainted with the scene going inside the corridors, this book would be an interesting read.
Depicting the life of an outstanding academician turned policymaker and eventually, the Head of the Government of the largest democracy, the book provides interesting insights into his style of working and governance amidst an alternative power-center in the whole setup.
However, there should be an even bigger motivation for reading this book. The circumstances presented in the book can be very well applied in many broader contexts. What this book does so brilliantly is that at times, it provides you with alternatives and helps you to assess the merits and demerits of those alternatives but that's only possible if one is patient enough to ponder over certain developments which might go unnoticed in one go.
The author mentions that this book is an attempt to portray the stature of Dr. Singh in a positive light, yet he doesn't shy away from pointing certain imperfections in his character which made him defang particularly during his second term as a PM.
The author does mention about his disastrous second term but the book seems primarily focussed on his first term when the author was the media advisor of the protagonist. In short, highly recommended but don't go for it if you are expecting any sensational revelations. Mar 25, Sai rated it it was amazing Shelves: When it comes to India's former Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh, numerous number of doubts and questions float in the mind of people.
Manmohan Singh has a stunning education background,vast experience as professor in top class universities and also in government agencies like planning commission. He was also a former reserve bank governor and has major role in rescuing India from inflation crisis in s and balance of payment crisis in He was the major architect of liberalization in India, which boosted the path of Indian economy. With these feathers on his cap, Dr. Manmohan being judged just by his tenure as Prime Minister especially UPA-2 without knowing him completely is something to feel pity.
Is his Prime Minister tenure really a failure? Is Dr. Manmohan a dummy puppet? Does Sonia Gandhi exercise more power than him and control him? Many more such questions are answered in the book "The accidental Prime Minister" , where the author and media adviser of Manmohan from Sanjaya Baru talks about the former Prime Minister in extensive way and answers many of our unanswered questions.
This book mostly talks about UPA-1, which is Dr. As the author Sanjaya Baru resigned from Prime Minister office in , details about his tenure from UPA-2 is limited to the author's knowledge. The author has exactly narrated the events that happened during his times in the Prime Minister office and also gives insights about the functioning of a Prime Minister office in general.
The difficulty of being the Prime Minister of a country can be felt while reading the book. It is a common practice for Indians to criticize the top people in our government, without knowing about them thoroughly. As the structure of Prime Minister office itself is limited to the knowledge of a common citizen, criticizing the head of government without understanding the ground level situation is unfair. Someone can be criticized for their flaws but maligning someone for something they didn't do is completely unjust.
Characterizing Dr. Manmohan Singh as powerless and his decisions are completely dominated by Sonia gandhi is only partially true as Dr. Manmohan was a man of his own on various issues and he is majorly responsible for UPA-1 becoming a success. This book mostly talks about the decisions taken by him, the decision which he was unable to take because of his limited powers and also about the denial of his legacy.
Author Sanjaya Baru portrays the true nature of Dr. Manmohan Singh and gives complete credit to his achievements. The limitations of power exercised by Dr. Manmohan Singh is clearly mentioned in his book. UPA-1 was the first congress-coalition government,where the congress government had coalition with Communists, whose ideology is completely different from INC.
This is one of the vital reason for the limitation of powers of Dr. Manmohan Singh along with the demands of other coalition parties. As everyone knows, Sonia limited his powers but only to an extent as Dr. Manmohan was able to dominate her in few issues, which many are unaware and these issues are widely discussed in this back. The department where Dr. Manmohan exercised complete authority and command is foreign policy and as a former Finance Minister and his experience in various countries, he got to know how the world dynamics is getting shaped up after globalization and his decisions to resolve Kashmir issues and sign nuclear deal with US are the clear examples.
The greatest monumental achievement of Dr. Manmohan Singh in his tenure as Prime Minister is boosting the nuclear capabilities of India by signing the nuclear deal with US amidst various troubles. He was surrounded and charged from all sides in signing this deal and how he was able to confront these misfortunes and attain triumph defines the legacy of Dr.
Manmohan Singh, which are unknown to many. The book also talks about the relation of Dr. Manmohan Singh with some of his council of ministers and the events surrounding them.
This gives detail about how some people in his own party are against him. This book also mentions about the weak speaking skills of Dr. Manmohan and how he was trained to be a better spokesperson. The author has clearly indicated both the strengths and weakness of Dr. Manmohan Singh in a balanced way. This book showcases how Dr. Manmohan Singh asks for needed advice without any hesitation and how he is hungry to learn more, especially about China.
Some of the personal conversations of the author Sanjaya Baru with Dr. Manmohan Singh are fascinating to read. The main motive of the book is to show the real image of Manmohan Singh and display it to people of India that Dr. Manmohan Singh is not complete;y dominated by Sonia Gandhi and also shows where her decisions influenced him and the areas where Dr.
Manmohan had complete authority. All the chapters in the book were keen on showing the image of Dr. Manmohan Singh in a better limelight than the image registered in the minds of common citizens and concurrently this book also never fails to display the weakness of Dr. Manmohan Singh and highlighted whenever he went wrong.
Although all the chapters are concentrated on the above areas, the epilogue of the book came to be a hard hitting one and was hard on the UPA-2 government and reveals how UPA-2 became an epic failure. This book at the end creates a pitiful image on Dr.
Manmohan Singh and generates anger on the people responsible for diminishing the extraordinary legacy of the extraordinary Dr. Manmohan Singh and altogether this book is an irresistible read for every Indian citizen to know the real face of Dr.
Manmohan Singh, especially for political gores which will influence and increase their known political knowledge. Jan 15, Minakshi Ramji rated it it was amazing. If I were to be honest, this book caught my eye in the airport bookstore only because of the controversy around the movie.